Wall Street Downvotes Reddit 21% After Reading Only the Title of a Quarter Where Profit Tripled

By Stocks News   |   3 months ago   |   Stock Market News
Wall Street Downvotes Reddit 21% After Reading Only the Title of a Quarter Where Profit Tripled

r/Overreaction, much? 

Well friends, Reddit just posted the best quarter of its life and got charged a fifth of its market cap for the privilege. Q2 revenue hit $804.9 million, up 61% from a year ago. Net income nearly tripled to $253 million. EPS landed at $1.25 against the $0.95 Wall Street expected, and Q3 guidance of $860 to $870 million cleared consensus with room to spare (the part that usually makes a stock go up, for the record). Every number a company can beat, Reddit beat.

And yet, shareholders went all “that don’t impress me much” as shares cratered 21% to $140.67 on Friday, on 6.6 times normal volume (so this wasn't three nervous hedge funds, it was a stampede).

Y tho? 

One sentence. That was the culprit. CEO Steve Huffman's shareholder letter called Google search referrals "choppy" and traffic "more volatile later in the quarter." Translation? Google's AI Overviews now answer your question right at the top of the results page, nobody scrolls down to the blue links anymore, and those blue links happen to be Reddit's front door. Google huffed, puffed, and blew the roof clean off the house that Huffman built.

Whereas, the market’s read is pretty simple on this one. The new-user pipeline is dying, the growth story is broken, get out before the door slams in yo face. And the chart agrees, with Reddit's cheeks thoroughly clapped from a $282 high down to spitting distance of the 52-week low at $119. This, of course, begs the question… is Google just the villain here? Not quite.

See, the same Google allegedly strangling Reddit's traffic is also Reddit's largest paying sugar daddy data-licensing customer. That's roughly $60 million a year, signed February 2024, part of a disclosed $203 million licensing book, all so Google's AI can train on twenty years of humans arguing with strangers. That deal is up for renewal right now, and word is Reddit is weighing whether to tighten Google's access. Because the AI shift cuts both ways. The more search gets automated, the scarcer real human conversation becomes, and a live archive of actual people telling you which mattress won't f*ck up your back is the one thing a chatbot can't fake. Huffman said it himself in the same letter: "People don't want a summary of Reddit; they want Reddit." Google's $60 million checkbook agrees. One fact, two readings, and Friday's tape only priced the sad one.

Which brings me to the catch here: the traffic slowdown is real, nobody has put a number on it yet, and Huffman sold 18,000 shares at roughly $197 on July 15, two weeks before the drop (about $3.6 million, for those keeping score at home). Easy, pitchforks. That was a 10b5-1 plan, the autopilot selling schedule executives lock in months ahead of time precisely so nobody can ask "did he know something?" A shrug, not a smoking gun. But it's also not the behavior of a guy sprinting to buy his own dip.

Meaning, this one goes on the watchlist. A renewal headline with a bigger dollar figure attached, or one more quarter of user numbers holding up under the AI Overview squeeze, and that -21% starts looking like a Black Friday doorbuster. If daily actives shrink next print, the market read it right and $140 is full price for a slowing story. Either way, Wall Street just did the most Reddit thing imaginable: read the title, skipped the thread, and finger blasted the downvote button.

At the time of publishing, Stocks.News holds positions in Google as mentioned in the article. 

 

Did you find this insightful?

Disclaimer: Information provided is for informational purposes only, not investment advice. We do not recommend buying or selling stocks. Stock price discussions are based on publicly available data. Readers should conduct their own research or consult a financial advisor before investing. Owners of this site have current positions in stocks mentioned throughout the site, Please Read Full Disclaimer for details Here https://app.stocks.news/page/disclaimer