Tesla’s FSD Approval Quest Takes a Detour as EU Regulators Hook Elon’s Safety Math to a Polygraph

By Stocks News   |   5 months ago   |   Stock Market News
Tesla’s FSD Approval Quest Takes a Detour as EU Regulators Hook Elon’s Safety Math to a Polygraph

"It's not a lie if you believe it." -George Costanza Elon Musk

Remember that episode of Seinfeld where Jerry is dating a police officer and is too embarrassed to admit he secretly watches a soap opera? She decides to put him on a polygraph to prove he's lying, so Jerry immediately turns to George (the greatest liar he knows) for advice on how to beat it.

George's answer has since gone down as one of the most legendary pieces of television wisdom ever delivered:

"It's not a lie if you believe it."

Well folks, it appears Tesla may have adopted that exact compliance strategy while trying to get Full Self-Driving approved across Europe.

Because according to a Reuters investigation, Tesla has been showing European regulators safety statistics that independent researchers say are about as trustworthy as George Costanza testifying under oath.

For the past year, Elon Musk and Tesla executives have repeatedly argued that Full Self-Driving is dramatically safer than human drivers. In some cases, Tesla has claimed vehicles using FSD can travel more than seven times farther between crashes than the average driver. 

Which considering everyone's taking Elon’s claim of sending data centers to space tomorrow seriously… isn’t really all that big of a deal to Tesla bros. European regulators, however, tend to be slightly more annoying about things like evidence.

The whole thing started because Tesla is trying to get wider approval for Full Self-Driving across Europe. 

Makes sense.

European sales have been rougher than Elon Musk’s relationship with literally anyone who’s worked for him, and FSD is supposed to be one of the company’s biggest growth engines going forward.

The problem is Reuters took a closer look at the numbers and found several comparisons that researchers say don't exactly pass the smell test.

According to the report, Tesla compares crash rates involving FSD-equipped vehicles against the average crash rate for all vehicles on American roads.

Including aging vehicles, commercial trucks, motorcycles, and all the beaters you see sitting in your local Walmart parking lot.

Which is kind of like estimating how many crimes could be stopped if every citizen became Batman.

Reuters also found Tesla compares accidents involving airbag deployments while using FSD against national crash statistics that include many less severe accidents.

Again, not exactly an apples-to-apples comparison.

Yet some pretty eye-popping conclusions still found their way into presentations sent to regulators.

One slide reportedly suggested FSD could have saved roughly 32,000 lives and prevented 1.9 million injuries.

Researchers say that estimate assumes every vehicle in America magically becomes an FSD-enabled Tesla and that every one of those Teslas is substantially safer than whatever vehicle it replaced. Which again, is not realistic.

As you’d expect, regulators aren't exactly taking Tesla’s marketing deck at face value.

The Dutch road authority, which approved FSD for use in the Netherlands earlier this year, said it does not rely on marketing claims or external statistics when evaluating systems like this.

Instead, officials say they conduct their own testing, audits, and verification processes. 

Swedish regulators struck a similar tone, saying any approval process would look far beyond headline safety numbers. One European transportation safety advocate even argued that if Tesla wants to make major safety claims, the data should be independently reviewed by universities and outside researchers before regulators start treating it as fact,

Meanwhile, Tesla desperately wants Europe to open the gates. The company has made it clear that FSD approval around the world is a major part of its strategy to revive growth across the region after sales took a beating last year.

And with China already beating their butt behind the woodshed on price and value… Tesla needs something more exciting than another price cut to convince buyers to open their wallets.

So it goes without saying the next few months are vital. For FSD to gain approval across the entire European Union, member states representing at least 65% of the bloc’s population must sign off.

Until then, individual countries can approve the technology on their own.

Maybe Tesla is right. Maybe FSD really is far safer than human drivers. The problem is that once regulators think you're playing fast and loose with the data, every claim gets viewed through that lens. And that's not exactly the position you want to be in when you're asking Europe for approval.

At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News holds positions in Tesla as mentioned in the article.

Did you find this insightful?

Disclaimer: Information provided is for informational purposes only, not investment advice. We do not recommend buying or selling stocks. Stock price discussions are based on publicly available data. Readers should conduct their own research or consult a financial advisor before investing. Owners of this site have current positions in stocks mentioned throughout the site, Please Read Full Disclaimer for details Here https://app.stocks.news/page/disclaimer