Netflix: How are you liking our new video podcasts?
Wells Fargo: “MAKE A F***ING HIT.”
The company that turned “Are you still watching?” into a threat, (read: Netflix), took another yuge L Friday after Wells Fargo answered, “Define ‘watching.’”
Shares plunged 4%, putting Netflix on pace to renew Shareholder Pain for a third consecutive week.
Wells Fargo marked Netflix “Not for Me,” cutting the stock to “Underweight” and sending its $80 price target into the Upside Down at $57.
His chief complaint?
Reed Hastings and his fellow cable-tv hijackers have forgotten that producing actual hits is an important part of running the world’s largest streaming service.
“Engagement trends look worrying to us,” Johnny Raincloud Cahall wrote, estimating subscribers watched an average of 1.6 hours per day during the first half of the year.
Now, 1.6 hours may sound like plenty of quality time spent watching hot people sell mansions to other hot people.
But once Cahall adjusted for Netflix’s password-sharing extortion campaign crackdown and geographic mix, viewing was down roughly 8% from 2023.
Translation: America can only rewatch Breaking Bad so many times.
The analyst also noted that Netflix’s share of U.S. television viewing has slipped below 8%, while hours watched among its 100 biggest original titles declined during the first half.
And somehow, the second half looks even more fugly.
Cahall’s base case calls for viewing hours from Netflix’s top 100 originals to yeet 21% year over year as the platform struggles to produce the kind of breakout series that used to turn office watercoolers into spoiler-filled conversations.
“NFLX has lacked big original series & it’s showing,” he wrote.
Cue Netflix executives greenlighting Stranger Things: The Nursing Home Years.
Believe it or not, Netflix’s problem isn’t a lack of spending. The company is lighting record amounts of money on fire across gaming, documentaries, reality television, live programming, and video podcasts in its increasingly desperate fistfight with YouTube for humanity’s last functioning attention span.
But Wells Fargo fears all those side quests may be coming at the expense of the massive scripted hits that convince subscribers Netflix is worth keeping between seasons of Bridgerton You.
“Wait… people aren’t keeping a $25 subscription for Pete Davidson’s thoughts?” -you, understandably stunned
“We see breakout hits as a must for the stock to work again,” Cahall said.
In other words, another cooking competition probably isn’t getting this pig airborne.
January’s engagement report (scheduled to arrive alongside Netflix’s fourth-quarter results) now looms as the next potential horror premiere. Cahall sees elevated churn risk heading into 2027 and trimmed his earnings estimates for both 2027 and 2028.
He also removed six entire turns from Netflix’s valuation multiple, dropping it from 21 times forward earnings to 15 times.
Stop! Stop! He’s already dead!
To be fair, Wells Fargo appears to be the only analyst at the sleepover who thinks everyone should go home.
Netflix’s average target sits near $93.88, with 35 analysts screaming “Buy,” 16 politely saying “Hold,” and precisely zero willing to attach their name to “Sell.”
Meanwhile, Evercore ISI raised its target from $100 to $110 this week, citing multiyear-high penetration rates in the U.S. and Japan.
So, depending on which highly compensated spreadsheet enthusiast you believe, Netflix is either worth $57 or $110.
Very helpful. Thanks, gentlemen.
Cahall conceded that Netflix could still drop a surprise global banger and send his downgrade directly to the analyst Hall of Shame.
Until then, Wells Fargo expects engagement to sink, churn to climb, and shareholders to keep bingeing Honey, I Shrunk the Portfolio.
New episodes every trading day.
At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News holds positions in Netflix as mentioned in the article.
Did you find this insightful?
Bad
Just Okay
Amazing
Disclaimer: Information provided is for informational purposes only, not investment advice. We do not recommend buying or selling stocks. Stock price discussions are based on publicly available data. Readers should conduct their own research or consult a financial advisor before investing. Owners of this site have current positions in stocks mentioned throughout the site, Please Read Full Disclaimer for details Here https://app.stocks.news/page/disclaimer
