Malls Are Dead, But Dick’s is Paying $2.4 Billion for a Mall Zombie Anyway (Delusion at its Finest)

When your stock is down 84% from its all-time high (and that high was nine years ago) you’re not in a “slump.” You’re in purgatory, just praying someone comes along with enough optimism (or delusion) to believe you’re worth saving. That’s been the vibe at Foot Locker for a while now. Once the king of mall-based sneaker culture, they’ve spent the last decade quietly losing relevance while pretending everything was fine.

Then, out of nowhere, Dick’s Sporting Goods reached that level of delusion… This morning, Dick’s announced it’s buying Foot Locker for $2.4 billion (a move about as random as they come). The offer gives Foot Locker shareholders $24 a share, which is a 66% premium over the stock’s 60-day average. Foot Locker’s stock promptly exploded, soaring over 80% in a single day. Because when you’ve been crawling through the desert for a decade, even a slightly chilled glass of tap water looks like salvation.

But this isn’t some feel-good comeback story for a brand that dressed its employees like NBA refs. This is about control. Specifically, control over Nike. See, Foot Locker and Dick’s are two of Nike’s biggest wholesale partners. And while Nike has spent years trying to push customers toward direct sales through its own app and stores, it’s recently warmed back up to good old-fashioned wholesaling. With this merger, Dick’s gets a massive bump in leverage. Suddenly, instead of being one of the big players, they’re the player. The combined company will have huge sway with Nike, plus access to a younger, urban demographic Foot Locker serves… one that Dick’s, with its suburban big-box stores, has never really cracked.

It’s also Dick’s first serious move into the international market. Foot Locker operates 2,400 stores across 20 countries. That gives Dick’s a global footprint practically overnight. And while Foot Locker has been trying to turn itself around under CEO Mary Dillon, the math hasn’t been kind. In Q1, they posted a $363 million net loss. Sales are slipping. Store traffic is slowing. Most of their locations are still stuck in shopping malls, which, as anyone who’s walked through one lately knows, is down bad. To their credit, Foot Locker had been making progress. They cut losses, updated stores, and even launched a strategic overhaul called the “Lace Up Plan”. But investors weren’t buying it… literally. Their stock was down over 40% this year before the buyout news hit.

And let me just say this: If you want a real-world example of where consumer behavior is headed, I’m living it. I’m playing in a men’s league softball tournament this weekend. I haven’t swung a bat since high school and had no cleats, no glove, nothing. Did I run to the nearest Dick’s or Foot Locker to get geared up? Nope. I bought everything on eBay. Some guy in Ohio shipped me a gently used glove and a pair of Under Armour cleats for less than fifty bucks, and they showed up two days later. That’s the world Foot Locker is fighting against… a world where convenience and price crush nostalgia and loyalty.

Of course, not everyone’s thrilled. Dick’s stock dropped nearly 10% on the news. Analysts like John Kernan at TD Cowen called it a “strategic mistake,” warning that big retail M&A tends to create more problems than value. He’s not wrong… historically, these kinds of deals rarely pan out the way the glossy press releases suggest.

But CEO Lauren Hobart is hoping that this one will be different. In her words, it’s a “transformative step” to create a global platform that better serves customers, brands, and shareholders. In other words: she thinks she can fix what Foot Locker couldn’t, and she’s willing to take the risk to do it.

PS: It’s a mess out there.

One day the market’s ripping, the next day it’s Black Monday all over again. Recent earning’s reports have been a total coin flip. One stock beats and explodes 30%… the next misses by a penny and gets sent to the Shadow Realm. And through it all, everyone’s begging for Jerome Powell to finally cave and cut rates.

But underneath all the panic headlines (“Inflation too sticky!” “Recession imminent!” “Tariffs round 4 incoming!”) something wild is happening…

We’re seeing violent price action. Especially in the small-cap space, where low floats and high anxiety are creating the perfect recipe for 100%+ pops before lunchtime. Some of these names are moving 200%+ in under 24 hours… and to our knowledge, NO ONE else is covering them.

Except us.

Stocks.News Premium members are getting first dibs on these stealth explosions… thanks to our squeeze signal scanner and real-time insider trading tracker that zeroes in on the money before the momentum shows up.

If you’ve been whiplashed by this market or feel like your strategy is stuck in 2022, it’s time to flip the script.

Premium gets you:

• Two breaking trade alerts per week
   
• Access to the same scanners we use to track CEO buys and Capitol Hill moves
   
• Our custom market sentiment tool (that actually works)
   
• Premium stock writeups packed with actual analysis (that’s not boring)

Go here to become a Stocks.News Premium member now.

Stock.News does not have positions in companies mentioned.