Earnings Flop: Micky D’s Swears It Doesn't Have a Strategy Issue, Executes Its U.S. President Anyway

By Stocks News   |   3 months ago   |   Stock Market News
Earnings Flop: Micky D’s Swears It Doesn't Have a Strategy Issue, Executes Its U.S. President Anyway

Ba Da Ba Ba Ba, They're Blaming It…

Ronald and the Gang posted earnings today, and they didn’t pull any punches. Case in point: shareholders got an earnings beat, revenue miss, and a human sacrifice all in one. "We don't have a strategy problem," Coach Kempczinski (read: CEO Chris Kempczinski) told analysts. "We simply didn't execute at the level we needed to." In the same breath, the company announced that Joe Erlinger, the man who executed the U.S. business for the last six years, was done effective immediately. Funny how that works.

In short, the receipts are as follows: adjusted EPS came in at $3.38 against the $3.32 Wall Street expected, revenue of $7.10 billion against a hoped-for $7.13 billion, and net income up to $2.36 billion from $2.25 billion a year ago. Global same-store sales rose 1.3%, exactly in line (the one number that behaved). The U.S. squeaked out 0.8%, and every basis point of it came from bigger checks. Traffic fell. Fewer Americans pulled into the drive-thru, and the ones who did paid more for the privilege.

Wait… how does an affordability push make everything pricier, you ask? Simple, McDonald's lets franchisees set their own prices, and corporate asked the whole system to run an Under $3 Menu with 10 items on it. Only 60% to 65% of stores actually did (in the other third of the country, that menu is an urban legend). Corporate left the "$3" definition loose enough that some operators responded to the value initiative by raising the price of small fries. Headquarters also pulled back on the national digital deals that feed its loyalty program, and, in Kempczinski's own words, "a fairly significant amount of price got taken in Q2." 

That said, the quarter had other self-inflicted wounds. Too many complicated launches slowed the kitchens, stretched service times, and dented customer satisfaction scores. The comparison was also brutal as last spring McDonald's was riding the Minecraft movie tie-in, with feral teenagers screaming "chicken jockey" at movie screens and buying McNuggets on the way home. This year's big swing was a World Cup campaign that whiffed during the biggest sporting event ever staged on American soil. Executives now say the U.S. business should be back on track with expectations in 2027. Woof. 

And then… the guillotine came out. Pour one out for Erlinger, who brought the Snack Wrap back from the dead and still got wrapped. His replacement is Skye Anderson, a 26-year company lifer who started in the finance department in 2000, ran the books for McDonald's Australia, and was most recently chief operating officer of McDonald's USA. Which means the person promoted to fix the execution problem was, until Tuesday, the chief operating officer of the execution problem. (congrats, here's a flaming bag of fries). 

Over in the few but bright spots, the new Refreshers and crafted sodas are pulling in fresh visits and fattening the average check, and Red Bull Energizers hit menus in the coming weeks (nothing says "back on track" like selling Dragonberry heart palpitations next to Happy Meals). Oh, and one more casualty from the call ended up being that the 50,000-restaurants-worldwide target was taken to the woodshed (read: pushed back from the end of 2027 to the end of 2028). CFO Ian Borden cited the consumer environment and inflation in development costs. Translation: building a McDonald's got expensive as sh*t too.

But alas, "We don't have a strategy problem" is a sentence with a documented life expectancy. Every coach who insists the playbook is fine eventually learns that the playbook stays and the coach doesn't. Anderson gets until 2027 to make the plays work in a system where a third of the stores can't be bothered to sell a $3 McChicken, and she's probably the right hire… 26 years inside this machine, she knows where every grease trap is. But she'd better deliver. Her new boss just showed the whole company what happens to people with an execution problem. No pressure. Until next time, friends… 

 

At the time of publishing, Stocks.News holds positions in McDonalds as mentioned in the article. 

 

Did you find this insightful?

Disclaimer: Information provided is for informational purposes only, not investment advice. We do not recommend buying or selling stocks. Stock price discussions are based on publicly available data. Readers should conduct their own research or consult a financial advisor before investing. Owners of this site have current positions in stocks mentioned throughout the site, Please Read Full Disclaimer for details Here https://app.stocks.news/page/disclaimer