CarMax Investors: So what's the turnaround plan?
CarMax: How ‘bout that USA men’s soccer team? You think they’ll actually do something this World’s Cup?
Note to self: if I ever become CEO of a publicly traded company, don't spend an entire earnings call explaining that the turnaround plan exists and then refuse to show anyone the turnaround plan.
Car Fox and friends absolutely put Wall Street in a body bag this quarter.
For instance, revenue came in at $8 billion versus $7.4 billion expected. And earnings landed at $1.31 per share versus estimates calling for just 95 cents.
Then the stock immediately fell 9%. Which is usually not what happens when you beat estimates by a country mile.
But investors weren't focused on what CarMax did last quarter. They were focused on what CarMax plans to do next. And unfortunately, the answer they got was essentially: "I have concepts of a plan."
So where did it go wrong?
Well, new CEO Keith Barr spent much of the earnings discussion talking about a massive turnaround strategy that will supposedly unlock growth, improve efficiency, leverage technology, enhance customer experiences, create shareholder value, cure male pattern baldness, and possibly achieve world peace (okay, I made those last two up, just in case you couldn’t tell.)
The only problem? The actual details aren't arriving until everyone’s eating golden delicious apples and raking maple leaves off their lawn (read: the fall).
Barr says he's spent his first three months learning the business, identifying opportunities, and building a multi-year roadmap for the company. Which is probably the correct thing to do if you're a CEO.
It's just not exactly the kind of answer investors love hearing after they just watched the stock rally 25% this year. Because while the headline numbers looked fantastic, the stuff underneath the hood still sounds like a car that makes weird noises when you turn left.
Total gross profit fell 4.4%. Net income dropped nearly 12%. And perhaps most importantly, gross profit per retail used vehicle declined another $230 from last year's record level.
Unfortunately for Barr, that’s the number shareholders actually care about. Because selling more cars is nice. Making less money on each one is less nice.
CarMax says the pressure is largely self-inflicted. Management continues cutting prices to stimulate demand and fend off competition from their online car vending machine rival… Carvana.
Which is working... sort of. Retail and wholesale vehicle sales increased 3.3% during the quarter. Revenue grew more than 6%. Comparable used-vehicle sales only slipped 0.8%, which was better than analysts feared. The problem is this marks the fourth consecutive quarter of declining same-store sales.
So investors are now watching a company that keeps selling more cars overall while simultaneously making less money on each one and struggling to grow at existing locations.
Meanwhile, after clawing back from bankruptcy by the skin of their teeth after covid, Carvana continues to take market share in the used car internet parking lot.
As more and more Americans become willing to buy their next set of wheels from Carvana’s vending machine… that’s caused everyone else in the industry to have to continue to lower their prices.
Which brings us right back to CarMax’s margin problem.
When Jerome Powell finally handed over the keys to Kevin Warsh, most of the industry assumed the road ahead was about to get a whole lot smoother. Lower rates. Cheaper financing. More car sales. Everybody wins.
Instead, Kevin and friends spent last week reminding investors that not only are rates staying put... they could actually move higher from here.
So between shrinking margins, a used-car price war, and a Federal Reserve that may be headed in the wrong direction, investors aren't exactly lining up to buy into CarMax's turnaround story.
Then again, it's hard to buy into a turnaround plan when management hasn't actually shown you the turnaround plan yet.
At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News doesn’t hold positions in companies mentioned in the article.
Did you find this insightful?
Bad
Just Okay
Amazing
Disclaimer: Information provided is for informational purposes only, not investment advice. We do not recommend buying or selling stocks. Stock price discussions are based on publicly available data. Readers should conduct their own research or consult a financial advisor before investing. Owners of this site have current positions in stocks mentioned throughout the site, Please Read Full Disclaimer for details Here https://app.stocks.news/page/disclaimer
