CarMax’s $6B Car Lot Gets a $350M Activist Inspection As Carvana Leaves It in the Rearview

By Stocks News   |   8 months ago   |   Stock Market News
CarMax’s $6B Car Lot Gets a $350M Activist Inspection As Carvana Leaves It in the Rearview

If you or a loved one were dumb enough to “buy the dip” on Carmax stock… you may be entitled to financial compensation…

CarMax (+1%) just got a surprise visitor in the parking lot, and shockingly, it wasn’t someone trying to trade in a 2008 Ford Focus with three missing hubcaps.

Starboard Value rolled up with a $350 million stake in everyone’s favorite fox mechanic… and immediately asked if they could “take a quick look under the hood.” Translation: the activists are here.

According to reports, Starboard has built the massive position and already nominated two new board members, including its own CEO Jeff Smith and Frontdoor boss Bill Cobb. In other words: “This can go the easy way… or the hard way.”

The good news for CarMax is that Starboard isn’t showing up with pitchforks just yet.

Shockingly, the firm says it actually likes the incoming CEO, Keith Barr, who officially starts this month after running InterContinental Hotels Group.

Their hope is that if he could overhaul a global hotel chain, maybe he can do the same thing for CarMax… minus the room service and tiny shampoo bottles.

Because right now… the company could use a tune-up.

CarMax was once the cool kid in the used-car business… one of the pioneers of online vehicle sales before everyone and their cousin decided to start selling cars on the internet.

But in recent years the company has been getting smoked by newer rivals… most notably Carvana, whose stock has been on a heater while CarMax shares have turned into a never ending opportunity to buy the dip.

Over the last 12 months, CarMax stock has dropped about 43%, shrinking the company’s value to roughly $6 billion. Meanwhile Carvana (which in 2022 looked like it was about six minutes away from selling the office furniture on Craigslist) is up 86%. Side note: whoever had the absolute titanium spine to buy Carvana at the bottom and ride it to a 7,000%+ gain… take a bow. That’s generational wealth behavior.

Anyways, back to the activist convo… Starboard thinks the fix for CarMax is actually pretty simple.

CarMax already sells over a million vehicles per year and runs more than 250 physical car lots, giving it a huge advantage most online-only competitors don’t have… customers can actually show up and kick the tires. The activist firm believes the company just needs to run the operation better.

According to them, that includes refurbishing cars faster, cutting more than $300 million in overhead, improving the customer experience, and introducing more dynamic pricing to move more inventory faster.

In other words… replace a few humankind for Claudebots named Larry and Linda… and steal a few executives from Carvana.

Starboard also points to its past investments in Cars.com and RB Global as proof it knows a thing or two about vehicle marketplaces. So now the ball is in Keith Barr’s court.

Because if he manages to spark a turnaround, Starboard will happily sit back and take credit for the whole thing.

But if CarMax’s next earnings call starts with a phrase that resembles “please don’t be mad at me…” Let’s just say activist investors don’t usually show up with $350 million to play the role of silent partner.

At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News holds positions in Ford as mentioned in the article.

Did you find this insightful?

Disclaimer: Information provided is for informational purposes only, not investment advice. We do not recommend buying or selling stocks. Stock price discussions are based on publicly available data. Readers should conduct their own research or consult a financial advisor before investing. Owners of this site have current positions in stocks mentioned throughout the site, Please Read Full Disclaimer for details Here https://app.stocks.news/page/disclaimer