“The money Skylar Apollo, where is the rest?” -Walter White private equity investors
Well folks, it appears Wall Street's favorite game of financial make-believe just ran into a small problem. The investors started reading the rules.
Because Apollo just capped withdrawals from its Apollo Debt Solutions fund after redemption requests exploded to nearly 17% during the second quarter.
That's about $2.4 billion worth of investors simultaneously deciding they'd prefer cash over whatever private loans are sitting inside the portfolio.
Unfortunately, Apollo only wants to hand out 5% at a time. But don’t worry they definitely absolutely have the money. Probably.
Because as we all know, the hallmark of a perfectly healthy fund is putting traffic cops in front of the withdrawal window.
The situation is especially awkward because these private credit funds were marketed as a way for wealthy investors to enjoy the juicy yields of private lending without giving up too much liquidity.
The sales pitch was essentially: "Here's a bunch of assets that are hard to sell... but don't worry, you'll still be able to get your money back."
Turns out that works great when three people want out. It gets considerably more complicated when an entire crowd starts heading for the parking lot at the same time.
According to Apollo, redemption requests hit 16.8% during the quarter, up from an already uncomfortable 11.2% in the previous quarter.
And while Apollo says most of the challenges are tied to software-related investments, that's probably not the detail investors are focused on right now.
They're focused on the giant "Please Wait" sign hanging over their money.
Then again, if you're going to have a liquidity problem, it's comforting to know all your friends have one too.
Earlier this month, BlackRock’s younger, poorer brother (read: Blackstone) put similar withdrawal limits on its YUGE BCRED private credit fund after redemption requests surged.
Partners Group has also warned it may need to do the same thing.
But again, according to the private credit industry… nothing to see here…
Ever since the great financial crisis… private credit has been one of finance's hottest trades. Investors loved the higher yields. Fund managers loved the fees. Everybody loved the performance.
Then somebody accidentally introduced the one thing every liquidity mismatch hates: Actual withdrawals.
As private markets veteran Sunaina Sinha Haldea described it, the industry is now "testing the plumbing."
Translation: We're about to find out whether this thing was built by SpaceX engineers... or the folks responsible for the Titan submersible.
Ironically, while retail investors are busy stampeding toward the exits, some of the largest institutions on Earth are walking through the front door.
Several firms say pensions, endowments, and other institutional giants are actually increasing private credit allocations because periods of chaos tend to produce the best lending deals.
But institutions generally understand they're buying long-term, illiquid assets. Retail investors often hear the word "withdrawal" and assume it means whenever they feel like it.
The bigger lesson here is that liquidity is one of those things nobody thinks about until it disappears. Kind of like oxygen. Or toilet paper during a pandemic.
And right now, “suits” across the private credit world are discovering that owning assets which take months to sell becomes considerably less fun when everyone wants their money back by Friday.
At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News doesn’t hold positions in companies mentioned in the article.
Did you find this insightful?
Bad
Just Okay
Amazing
Disclaimer: Information provided is for informational purposes only, not investment advice. We do not recommend buying or selling stocks. Stock price discussions are based on publicly available data. Readers should conduct their own research or consult a financial advisor before investing. Owners of this site have current positions in stocks mentioned throughout the site, Please Read Full Disclaimer for details Here https://app.stocks.news/page/disclaimer
