Amazon’s Ad Auction Gets Raided After FTC Finds a Suspicious Mystery Bidder (Andy Jassy, That You?)

By Stocks News   |   2 months ago   |   Stock Market News
Amazon’s Ad Auction Gets Raided After FTC Finds a Suspicious Mystery Bidder (Andy Jassy, That You?)

Amazon: “You only pay slightly more than the second-highest bidder.”

Also Amazon: allegedly invents the second-highest bidder.

The Fun Police just kicked down Amazon’s front door and went full “I’ll sue your cardboard ass” over an alleged $20 billion game of “the house always wins.” 

According to the FTC’s lawsuit, Amazon “secretly and systematically overcharged” more than 1.2 million advertisers since 2019… including over 500,000 small and medium-sized businesses.

“How does one allegedly shake down an algorithm?” -you, taking notes 

Well, under that system, advertisers submit bids for sponsored placement. The winner is supposed to pay only slightly more than the second-highest bid.

It’s essentially eBay for companies willing to pay $14 so their garlic press appears above 37 identical garlic presses.

But according to regulators, Amazon wasn’t satisfied with letting actual advertisers determine the price.

(If you’ve ever seen Adam Sandler in Uncut Gems, the FTC is accusing Amazon of running the same fake-bidder scam… minus the part where Grandpa accidentally wins the opal). 

The company allegedly created a higher “proxy” bid using what its own documents described as an “invented auction participant.”

Nothing improves a competitive auction quite like competing against the guy running the auction amirite?

The FTC claims Amazon secretly introduced this system in 2019 through something called a “soft reserve price”... a hidden surcharge that pushed the winner’s bill above the price produced by the real auction.

And the fun police claim the company made the change because executives (read: Jeff Bezos) were unhappy with how much money its advertising business was generating.

And apparently, the answer wasn’t “sell more ads.” It was “invent someone willing to bid more.”

The FTC says Amazon then spent years testing how high it could push prices before advertisers noticed and lowered their bids.

One internal document described the strategy as “hoping that advertisers don’t notice and decrease bids or ad spend.”

The customer-first culture remains undefeated.

The lawsuit claims Amazon carefully increased the surcharges before huge shopping events like Prime Day and Black Friday, allowing it to squeeze extra cash from advertisers without triggering suspicion.

By 2024, Sponsored Products advertisers were paying their full bid about 80% of the time… up from between 30% and 40% in 2021.

That’s awfully first-price-auction behavior for a company still telling everyone they were participating in second-price auctions.

And would you know it? The surcharge machine worked beautifully.

Amazon’s advertising operation hauled in more than $68 billion last year, making it the world’s third-largest digital advertising business behind Google and Meta.

Regulators claim more than $20 billion of that money came from hidden overcharges.

And because sellers generally don’t eat higher advertising costs out of the goodness of their hearts, the FTC says much of the bill was eventually passed along to shoppers through higher prices on groceries, household goods, and other essentials.

So what does Andy Jassy think about all of this?

He and his overnight-delivery cartel skipped Fauci’s “plead the Fifth” strategery and chose violence. 

Amazon denied the allegations, branded the case a “misguided lawsuit,” and put the FTC itself on trial for aggravated reading comprehension. 

The company argues that the FTC reviewed 1.5 million pages of documents and cherry-picked a handful of simplified internal messages to manufacture the appearance of a companywide conspiracy.

Amazon also says average winning bids for search ads fell by 50% between 2019 and 2024, while its advertising improvements saved customers approximately $8 billion between 2021 and 2025.

Cancel the lawsuit and get these men fitted for capes. 

Meanwhile, the FTC and states are seeking civil penalties, refunds for advertisers, and a court order stopping the alleged practices.

If you’ve been following along with Stocks.News long enough, you know this is familiar territory for Bezos’ Everything Store.

Amazon agreed to a $2.5 billion settlement with the FTC last year over allegations that it treated Prime like the Hotel California: Customers could check out anytime they liked, but they could never leave. 

The company is also preparing for another FTC trial over allegations that it used monopoly power to inflate prices and crush third-party sellers.

Amazon denies wrongdoing in that case, too.

As for its advertisers, they can finally celebrate winning Amazon’s auctions.

They may have only needed to outbid Amazon’s imaginary friend to do it.

At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News holds positions in Amazon, Google, and Meta as mentioned in the article.

Did you find this insightful?

Disclaimer: Information provided is for informational purposes only, not investment advice. We do not recommend buying or selling stocks. Stock price discussions are based on publicly available data. Readers should conduct their own research or consult a financial advisor before investing. Owners of this site have current positions in stocks mentioned throughout the site, Please Read Full Disclaimer for details Here https://app.stocks.news/page/disclaimer