Alibaba’s $10.2 Billion Share Sale Is a Warning About the True Cost of the AI Boom

By Stocks News   |   2 months ago   |   Stock Market News
Alibaba’s $10.2 Billion Share Sale Is a Warning About the True Cost of the AI Boom

There is an old rule in finance that investors tend to forget during every market boom throughout history: Follow the money.

In the case of artificial intelligence, the money is increasingly coming from shareholders.

Alibaba shares fell as much as 10% in Hong Kong on Monday after the Chinese tech leader announced a $10.2 billion placement of newly issued shares. The company plans to use all the net proceeds to finance its artificial-intelligence ambitions.

Alibaba will issue 710 million shares at approximately $14.38 apiece, a substantial discount to Friday’s closing price of $15.70. The stock promptly fell toward the placement price, while Alibaba’s U.S.-listed shares dropped 3.4% in premarket trading.

None of this should be surprising. When a company creates and sells new shares below the prevailing market price, existing shareholders are diluted. Their ownership of the business becomes smaller unless the money raised eventually generates enough profit to compensate them.

That last part is where things become considerably more complicated.

Alibaba has committed to investing at least $56.6 billion in AI and cloud infrastructure over three years. The company clearly believes AI will become a major driver of its future growth, and it has some obvious advantages. Alibaba already operates one of China’s largest cloud-computing businesses and has developed a competitive family of AI models.

But being well positioned to spend money on AI is not the same thing as being certain to earn an attractive return from it.

The share sale comes just days after Alibaba reported that its profit fell 75% in the June quarter. Capital expenditure, meanwhile, jumped 75% to approximately $10.1 billion as the company poured money into computing infrastructure.

Alibaba is now asking shareholders to accept a remarkable arrangement. Its enormous AI spending is already weighing heavily on profit, so it is issuing more shares to obtain another $10.2 billion for even more AI spending.

This may eventually prove to be a brilliant investment. It may also be evidence that the AI boom is entering the stage when ambition begins to outrun internally generated cash.

Companies generally finance investments using cash produced by their existing businesses, borrowed money or newly issued stock. The strongest projects can often be funded internally because the underlying company produces enough cash to support them. 

When businesses must repeatedly approach bondholders or shareholders for additional capital, investors should ask whether the expected opportunity is truly exceptional or merely exceptionally expensive.

Alibaba is far from alone.

Technology companies around the world are racing to construct data centers, purchase advanced chips and secure the electricity needed to operate them. Tencent’s capital expenditure rose 65% from the previous quarter to approximately $7.9 billion during the June quarter. The top American tech royalty are spending similarly astonishing sums.

Each company believes it must invest aggressively because falling behind in AI could threaten its future. That reasoning may be perfectly rational for each individual business. Collectively, however, it creates the conditions for enormous overinvestment.

This is how capital-intensive booms typically work. One company increases spending, forcing its competitors to respond. The resulting demand raises the price of chips, computing capacity, electricity and technical talent. Those higher costs then require still more capital, even though nobody can yet know which companies will capture the eventual profits.

Investors often focus on the projected size of the market without paying enough attention to the price companies must pay to compete in it.

Alibaba may generate tremendous revenue from AI. But revenue is not profit, and profit is not cash flow. If the company must spend nearly $57 billion building the infrastructure required to produce that revenue, the ultimate return on its investment could be far less impressive than the growth figures suggest.

There is another issue. The more money companies raise from investors to finance AI infrastructure, the more dependent AI valuations become on the continued willingness of investors to supply that money.

Rising share prices make issuing stock more attractive. The proceeds finance additional AI spending, which supports demand throughout the technology industry and strengthens the narrative behind rising share prices. The loop can continue for a considerable period of time.

But it still requires belief.

Shareholders must believe the eventual profits will justify today’s spending. Lenders must believe the companies involved will produce enough cash to repay their debts. Technology executives must believe that slowing down would be more dangerous than continuing to spend.

Once that belief weakens, the same cycle can begin operating in reverse.

Nobody knows whether AI investment will ultimately produce the profits needed to justify these enormous expenditures. But when a company’s profit falls 75% and its next move is to dilute shareholders for another $10.2 billion, investors should at least begin asking how much longer the spending can outrun the returns.

At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News doesn’t hold positions in companies mentioned in the article.

Did you find this insightful?

Disclaimer: Information provided is for informational purposes only, not investment advice. We do not recommend buying or selling stocks. Stock price discussions are based on publicly available data. Readers should conduct their own research or consult a financial advisor before investing. Owners of this site have current positions in stocks mentioned throughout the site, Please Read Full Disclaimer for details Here https://app.stocks.news/page/disclaimer