Trump Puts a 20% Vig on Hormuz, and Every Airline Guide in Just Went on the Clock

“Fugayzi, fugazi. It's a whazy. It's a woozie. It's fairy dust. It doesn't exist. It's never landed. It is no matter. It's not on the elemental chart.” - the curve

Donny Vig (read: Trump) just turned the planet's most important 21 miles of water into a tollbooth. On Monday he restored the blockade on Iranian ports and announced that the U.S. will now be running a protection racket "reimbursed, at the rate of 20% on all cargo" transiting the Strait of Hormuz… the chokepoint a fifth of the world's oil squeezes through. Crude did what crude does, WTI jumping to $78.74, up about 7% in two weeks. And the man capped the whole thing off by declaring America "THE GUARDIAN OF THE HORMUZ STRAIT". Bigly. 

Naturally, investors heard one thing and one thing only: buy energy, dump airlines, move on. Delta's down 8% since June 30, United's down 11% in two weeks, so the fuel risk must be priced in, right? Well… half right. The stocks repriced… the guides didn’t. 

In short, airlines promise full-year earnings based on the fuel forward curve… which is just the market's price for future fuel on the day the promise gets written. Fuel is 20 to 30% of an airline's cost base, so every guide is really a YOLO bet that the curve holds. Delta made its bet on July 10, affirming full-year EPS of $6.50 to $7.50 with a Q3 fuel assumption of roughly $3.15 a gallon, set off the July 2 curve… the same day Ed Bastian went on CNBC and called 20% higher airfares "sustainable" (the confidence on this man). Spoiler: Everybody in this story is charging somebody 20%.

Which brings me to the math here. Delta earned $2.20 a share in the first half. The midpoint of that guide is $7.00. So the back half has to produce roughly $4.80… 68% of the entire year, promised in advance. And the cushion under that $3.15 fuel number? EIA Gulf Coast jet fuel spot was $2.816 the week of July 3, and airlines pay call-it 20 to 30 cents over spot all-in. Meaning, Delta was raw-dogging the fuel curve the day the ink dried. Since then we’ve seen an orgy of Hormuz attacks, US strikes, and now Donny's 20% vig. The guide isn't broken yet… but every dollar of crude from here eats straight out of that 68%, and I've covered enough earnings seasons to know "affirmed" has a shelf life.

Aaaaand yet, that’s where United comes into play. They are the first airline forced to speak since the tollbooth went up. Scott Kirby, who spent the Fourth of July telling employees United is "the best airline in the history of aviation" in front of a flag-painted 787, reports tomorrow. Analysts already cut his number 8.3% in 60 days to about $1.80, which hands Kirby a free option: guide the back half lower, blame the fuel, and nobody can call it a miss. And if his Q3 fuel assumption prints above $3.15, Delta's week-old "affirmed" guide becomes historical fiction.

That said, this can all evaporate, sure. Iran was apparently shopping for negotiations as recently as July 9, the Versailles ceasefire lasted 26 days, and one friendly headline torches the whole crude premium. Airlines hedge. Bastian will happily charge your sorry a** another 20% for the seat. A merely in-line United print probably takes off out of an 11% hole.

Translation: Don’t short the hole. Watch one number tomorrow… Kirby’s fuel line. Above $3.15, and every promise this sector made in July was written on a curve that no longer exists. In other words, Donny is selling protection to every ship in the strait… nobody sold any to the airlines. Place your bets accordingly, friends. Until next time…

 

At the time of publishing, Stocks.News holds positions in United as mentioned in the article.