SpaceX’s $1.75T Valuation Climbs Into Morningstar’s Barber Chair, Loses $970 Billion off the Top

Well this is awkward.

After spending months listening to Wall Street, Twitter, Reddit, YouTube, TikTok, and approximately 47 different  financial gurus explain why SpaceX was about to become the most valuable company in human history...

Morningstar crashed the party with a calculator and chose mathematical violence.

The research firm released a note this week arguing that SpaceX is actually worth a LOT less. Not even the $1.5 trillion valuation private investors have been tossing around like free T-shirts at a basketball game. Just $780 billion.

Which if you do the math, means Morningstar thinks SpaceX is currently worth about half of what the IPO hype machine is suggesting.

Morningstar is simply the first brave soul willing to stand in front of the Elon freight train and wave a red flag. With SpaceX expected to go public in just over two weeks at a reported $1.75 trillion valuation and a $75 billion raise, you can bet more skeptics will soon be crawling out of the woodwork. 

Naturally, investors have been treating the deal like the second coming of Nvidia.

Morningstar... not so much. According to the analysts, the biggest issue isn't rockets. And it isn't Starlink’s space data center pitch. It's xAI.  Apparently the AI division is the thing keeping Morningstar analysts awake at night. 

The firm described xAI as a potential "material threat of value destruction," which is analyst-speak for, "This thing could get expensive real fast."

The analysts also said the business has an "indeterminate economic moat," which is just a fancy way of admitting nobody really knows what the moat is supposed to be yet.

That said, they're not completely bearish. Morningstar actually expects the stock could rally after the IPO anyway.

Because the setup is basically catnip for momentum traders.

You've got a tiny float, every investment bank on Earth hyping the deal. The AI mania is still red hot thanks to all the semiconductors…

And you've got a fast-track path into the Nasdaq 100 just 15 trading days after listing. That's a recipe that can keep a stock levitating longer than fundamentals might suggest.

But underneath all the excitement sits one very inconvenient detail. SpaceX is still losing money. And we’re talking a LOT of cheddar.

The company posted a net loss of $4.28 billion in its latest quarter after losing $4.94 billion during 2025.

And when you actually look under the hood, one division is carrying the entire operation on its back. Starlink generated $3.26 billion in quarterly revenue and accounted for 69% of total company sales (which also happens to be Elon’s favorite number).

Meanwhile, the traditional space business lost $619 million on an operating basis and xAI burned another $2.5 billion.

Even SpaceX acknowledged the risks in its IPO filing. The company flat-out warned investors that it has a history of losses and may never become profitable. Which is not exactly the sort of language you print on commemorative IPO coffee mugs.

Then there's the valuation.

AJ Bell analyst Dan Coatsworth pointed out that a $1.75 trillion market cap would value SpaceX at roughly 67 times sales. For comparison, Nvidia trades at around one-third of that multiple. And we’ve already got guys like Michael Burry (Mr. Big Short himself) accusing Jensen of artificially boosting earnings via accounting fraud. Needless to say, there’s a good chance investors with their heads screwed on right won’t be foaming at the mouth to throw their entire retirement into Elon’s fantasy.

Of course, none of this means the IPO will flop.

We've seen plenty of companies ignore valuation gravity for months (or even years) before reality eventually catches up.

Just ask anyone who thought Beyond Meat would replace every cow on Earth or that Nikola's gravity-powered truck was the future of transportation.

For now, SpaceX remains one of the most anticipated IPOs in market history. And unless somebody uncovers a genuine smoking gun that fundamentally changes the story, I wouldn't expect a single Morningstar note to convince Elon loyalists to abandon spaceship.

At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News doesn’t hold positions in companies mentioned in the article.