SoFi’s Bull Case Gets Put on Ice as Chime Bails and Shorts Allege “Trust Me Bro” Accounting (-13%)

“When I die, have Sofi lower the casket into the grave just so the company can let me down one last time…” -Sofi investors, probably

Well folks, Money Twitter’s favorite “innovative” stock released its Q1 numbers and things looked hot at the start of the call.

The “holy trifecta” of financials (revenue, ebitda, and net income) all passed the test with flying colors. With revenue popping 41% to a record $1.1 billion.

Then CEO Anthony Noto turned up the heat even more and proudly announced they added 1.1 million new members in the quarter… bringing the total to 14.7 million (+35% YoY). Which is the kind of stat that usually has traders going pants off at their desks.

Instead, the market looked at all of that and said “yeah… we’re good,” then proceeded to smash the sell button like it owed them money, sending shares down 13%.

Turns out, underneath all those sexy numbers… and all the mouthbreathers on Twitter claiming Sofi is the future of finance… There's one part of the business coughing up blood in the corner.

Ironically, it’s supposed to be the part of the business that sets them apart from everyone else. 

I’m talking about the tech platform… you know, the “banking-as-a-service” operation that’s been pitched as SoFi’s golden ticket to higher margins and a sexier valuation multiple. Well, that just fell 27% to $75M.

So what exactly was the reason? Pretty simple, really… they lost Chime, the same platform with 9-10 million active users and roughly $2.2 billion in revenue last year… which isn’t exactly the kind of customer you casually replace over a long weekend. 

And when you’re trying to sell Wall Street on a story built around diversification and multiple revenue streams… losing your biggest tenant in the “future of the business” bucket is about as comforting as hearing your pilot say “we’re gonna try something new here” mid-flight.

And if that wasn’t enough to make investors uncomfortable… Muddy Waters Research came circling like a shark that just located a wounded seal.

The firm disclosed a short position and accused SoFi of using aggressive accounting and off-balance sheet gymnastics to hide credit risk.

Of course, SoFi pretty much responded by saying “that’s cap,” claiming the report was misleading and hinting at legal action… which is always a fun little subplot to sprinkle into an already shaky narrative. 

Meanwhile, investors are sitting there trying to figure out whether this is noise… or the kind of thing that turns into a real problem six months from now. 

Because at the end of the day, this whole story still comes back to one thing… Credit. SoFi makes money lending to people. And that works great… until it doesn’t.

And to their credit (no pun intended), things didn’t look terrible this quarter.

The net charge-off rate actually improved to 2.07%, down from 2.37% last year… which isn’t exactly headline material, but it does suggest the credit side of the business hasn’t started doing anything reckless just yet. Although student loans ticked higher… which feels like one of those small details that ends up mattering more later. 

At the same time, lending revenue absolutely ripped… up 55% to $642 million. Their financial services segment (investing, credit cards, etc.) also grew 41% to $429 million… 

So what’s next for SoFi? Well, rather than playing it safe… they’ve decided to cannonball into the crypto deep end, rolling out trading and launching a stablecoin… because apparently “banking, lending, and credit risk” wasn’t quite enough excitement on its own.

The silver lining of this earnings disaster is that Sofi’s stock is now down 41% this year… so might be a great dip buy.

At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News doesn’t hold positions in companies mentioned in the article.