Saylor Gets Willy Wonka’d as MSCI Threatens to Revoke His Golden Index Ticket ($11.6B at Risk)
Interesting MicroStrategy Cotton, let’s see if it pays off for him.
Narrator: “Define pay off.”
Because Michael Saylor just got voted off the stock market’s island.
And the boat ride home could cost a whopping $11.6 billion.
Turns out index gatekeeper MSCI has ruled hoarding 848,000 Bitcoin might not qualify as running a legitimate business software company, putting Saylor's Strategy at risk of getting booted from its global indexes.
Dear Mr. Saylor, we've reviewed your business model and have a few questions about the $70 billion in magic internet money.
For the uninitiated, MSCI operates some of the world's most influential stock indexes, which are tracked by investment funds managing trillions of dollars.
Getting included means passive funds buy your shares whether your CEO spends his mornings improving shareholder value tweeting "Inevitable" over a picture of a Bitcoin riding a bald eagle into the sun.
It's the financial equivalent of getting invited to a party where everyone is required to bring you a gift.
And Saylor has been enjoying that arrangement while accumulating an absolutely biblical 848,000 Bitcoin.
Sadly for our Twitter vague-post king, MSCI has decided that companies whose primary business consists of buying Satoshi’s invention at ATH’s might not deserve the same treatment as companies that actually, you know, operate businesses.
Under its newly adopted framework, MSCI will screen companies for substantial operating assets.
Those that fail face five additional financial tests. Bomb four, and their golden ticket to passive-investor paradise could be revoked.
Oompa Loompa, doompa-dee-doo, Michael, your index days may be through.
Now, before the Bitcoin maximalists start organizing a candlelight vigil, Saylor hasn't actually been marched to the index gallows.
MSCI will name the potentially affected companies November 11, with the new rules taking effect after the November 30 closing bell.
Existing companies generally must fail the eligibility screen across two annual reporting periods before removal.
But investors are already calculating the damage.
According to JPMorgan, removing Strategy from MSCI indexes could trigger $2.8 billion in stock sales.
And if other index providers follow suit?
Another $8.8 billion.
“No wonder Strategy shares are down 6% today.” -you, a smoothbrain
And the implications extend beyond index funds smashing the sell button.
See, Saylor's Bitcoin accumulation strategy depends heavily on raising money from investors.
For a long time, Strategy’s “strategery” consisted of issuing shares at a premium to the value of its Bitcoin holdings, then using the proceeds to buy more Bitcoin.
The more Bitcoin Saylor bought, the more investors piled in. And the more investors piled in, the more Bitcoin he could buy.
Pretty sweet deal, right?
Well, until investors started getting sick of having their shares diluted, the stock's premium dried up, and Saylor had to start leaning on preferred shares. Which investors are now getting tired of, too.
Now MSCI is threatening to remove another source of dependable demand for Strategy's stock, potentially making future fundraising even harder.
Saylor, naturally, is pissed.
Speaking to Bloomberg Television, he accused MSCI of "imposing prejudicial values on digital assets" and insisted Strategy belongs in the operating-company category.
Totally disregarding Strategy previously warned that MSCI's proposal would barely affect its business while damaging the index provider's reputation.
Translation: You can't fire me. I quit. Also, please don't fire me.
November 11 is the next date to watch, when MSCI reveals its potentially affected companies.
Until then, Saylor has $70 billion worth of reasons to convince the financial establishment that buying Bitcoin qualifies as running a business.
At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News holds positions in Bitcoin and Strategy as mentioned in the article.