Ryan Cohen Tells GME Army He’s Buying eBay to Kill Amazon… Minor Issue: He’s Missing About $40B
Kid: Mommy, how did we get so rich?
Mom: Daddy bought calls on GME and EBay after Ryan Cohen convinced every mouthbreather on Reddit he was gonna takedown Amazon…
In what might be the most “trust me, bro” M&A pitch since… well, ever… GameStop just lobbed an unsolicited $125/share offer at eBay. That’s a $55.5 billion price tag.
For context? GameStop itself is worth… about $11-12 billion. So how tf is anyone supposed to take this as anything more than a meme stock trying to break the internet again?
Luckily for all of us, Michael Saylor’s BFF and GameStop’s fearless leader, Ryan Cohen was able to explain exactly how all of this made sense.
Just kidding. All he did was hop on CNBC, and utter the words: “We’re just getting started.” He also made it clear he hasn’t even sent an email, linkedin, or had a phone call with eBay’s management.
Even better?
When pressed for details on the structure of his offer, Cohen repeatedly told viewers to just look at the company’s website for the specifics. Which, correct me if I’m wrong… probably isn’t a great sign that this is much more than a dog and pony show to pump his own stock.
Cohen said: “We are offering half cash, half stock, and we have the ability to issue stock in order to get the deal done. But the full details of the offer on our website.” Translation: Roaring Kitty, do your thing… WallStreetBets do your thing… and boom we have the money.
And yeah, the math here is… creative. The offer represents a 20% premium to where eBay was trading, which explains why the stock jumped after hours. But even after popping, it stalled around $118… still well below the $125 offer price. That’s Wall Street sarcastically saying, “We’ll believe it when the check clears.”
Because the gap here is hard to ignore. GameStop has about $9.4 billion in cash and lined up a $20 billion financing letter, which still leaves a pretty massive hole to fill in a $55 billion deal. Cohen’s answer? Issue more stock. Classic move. If you can’t pay cash, just print more of yourself and hope everyone goes along with it.
Cohen’s thesis on this whole “we’re gonna take down Amazon” strategy is pretty simple: eBay is about as overweight as Lizzo in 2023… and he’s the guy holding the Ozempic needle.
He wants to hack out $2 billion in costs, mostly from marketing, while screaming that the business is under-earning and could crank profits way higher if someone just grew a spine.
In his brain: “If you’re spending $2.5B on marketing and users aren’t growing… maybe just stop?”
Not exactly revolutionary… but hey, it worked (kind of) at GameStop.
Then there’s the part where GameStop pitches its 1,600 stores as infrastructure for eBay’s marketplace. The vision includes turning those locations into authentication hubs, fulfillment centers, and live commerce studios. Because when you think cutting-edge e-commerce logistics, your brain obviously goes straight to a strip mall GameStop wedged between a vape shop and a Subway.
But there’s another thing at play here. It seems as if Ryan is trying to play the part of activist investor. Remember GameStop has already built about a 5% stake in eBay, mostly through derivatives, and Cohen is basically telling the board, “You have to look at this.” Fiduciary duty and all that.
And if they don’t?
He’s ready to take it straight to shareholders and turn this into a full-blown proxy fight.
Cohen’s track record is part of what makes this even remotely believable. He built Chewy and sold it for $3.35 billion, then became the patron saint of Reddit traders during the 2021 meme stock chaos, then took over GameStop and dragged it back from the brink with aggressive cost cuts.
Now he’s trying to pull off one of the most absurd acquisitions in market history… a company worth about $11 billion taking a swing at one worth four to five times that size.
If we see Roaring Kitty and Ryan Cohen go into full-blown activist mode… and they somehow get the GME army to pump shares high enough to actually make this thing viable…
Just go ahead and pencil them in for President and Vice President in 2028.
At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News holds positions in Gamestop and Amazon as mentioned in the article.