Ronald’s $8.5B AI Comeback Hits the Federal Fryer Over Alleged Big Mac Price-Fixing Scheme
McDonald’s: unveils $8.5B comeback strategy centered around AI…
Some obese customer: *wipes Big Mac sauce off fingers* “I’d like to sue someone please…”
So much for letting the robots save Dick and Mac’s Ray Kroc’s financial troubles…
As if the year couldn’t get any worse going into the “Holiday Pie” season, McDonald’s is facing a proposed nationwide class-action lawsuit accusing the fast-food giant of using an AI-powered pricing system to help thousands of supposedly independent franchisees set menu prices.
And according to the lawsuit, this isn’t just your standard “computers took our jobs” complaint.
Plaintiffs are claiming McDonald’s built a system that allegedly allowed thousands of competing franchisees to indirectly coordinate pricing.
Ronald McDonald 🤝 OPEC: “We’re merely discussing market conditions.”
The lawsuit, filed in federal court in Chicago, claims McDonald’s pricing platform pulls information from millions of daily transactions (including nonpublic store-level sales data) and uses it to recommend prices across its girthy U.S. franchise network.
Pretty big deal when 95% of McDonald’s 14,000 U.S. restaurants are independently owned and operated.
In theory, those franchisees are supposed to independently decide how much to charge you for your emotional-support McNuggets.
The lawsuit alleges McDonald’s built a system that effectively allows competing restaurants to share information they otherwise wouldn’t have access to.
Its conclusion?
“The result is algorithmic price-fixing aimed at customers who are already stretched thin.”
Your Honor, may I remind the court we used to have a Dollar Menu?
McDonald’s, naturally, says that’s a supersized load of McSh*t.
“AI does not set menu prices at McDonald’s restaurants… McDonald’s franchisees do,” the company said, calling the complaint “filled with inaccuracies.”
According to the Golden Arches, its pricing tools are optional. They provide franchisees with information and recommendations, but restaurant owners ultimately decide whether to follow them.
“$11.49 has a nice ring to it.” -Scam Altman, allegedly
Legally, that “suggested” part could make all the difference.
But supposedly telling the algorithm “nah, I’m good” wasn't always the end of the conversation.
Reuters reported that some franchisees felt pressured to use the system and were required to document when they deviated from its recommended prices.
McDonald’s called that characterization “speculative and uninformed.”
You are absolutely free to disagree with the robot. Please CC corporate.
Which brings us to Michael Thomas.
Thomas is the Illinois McDonald’s regular behind the lawsuit and, according to the complaint, is “price conscious.”
Thomas frequently orders a Quarter Pounder with cheese, fries and a Coke, but noticed that his usual order could cost different amounts at McDonald’s restaurants around his DeKalb neighborhood.
And the price discrepancies get much more violent when you leave DeKalb.
One customer interviewed in New York said a meal that costs him $9 in Brooklyn can run closer to $15 in Manhattan.
Again, a $15 meal in Manhattan isn't proof of the Great McConspiracy. Restaurants adjust prices for everything from rent and wages to local demand.
The antitrust question is how thousands of those prices got cooked up in the kitchen.
McDonald’s says its AI-enhanced system can consider a restaurant’s sales, location, competitors’ prices and other factors to determine what it considers an optimal menu price.
Plaintiffs argue that feeding nonpublic data from independently owned restaurants into one centralized pricing machine crosses the antitrust line.
Which makes that infamous $18 Connecticut Big Mac meal a little more interesting. Its franchise owner previously sued Mickey D’s alleging the company’s pricing tool recommended the $18 price.
And McDonald’s already has an affordability problem. Its own figures show average menu prices jumped 40% between 2019 and 2024, helping send lower-income customers searching for cheaper calories elsewhere.
The company has responded with value menus and cheaper meal deals, but getting franchisees onboard isn't automatic.
CEO Chris Kempczinski said in August that only about 60% of U.S. restaurants were offering its proposed lineup of 10 items below $3.
“That’s not something that we just flip the switch on,” Kempczinski said. “It requires conversations with franchisees.”
The lawsuit seeks class-action status and damages. McDonald’s says it will vigorously defend itself.
And with shares already down 23% YTD, Ronald could probably use a win.
Instead, one of the AI tools meant to help modernize the Golden Arches is now sitting in federal court accused of helping thousands of restaurants coordinate prices.
At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News holds positions in McDonald’s and Coca-Cola as mentioned in the article.