Reddit Gets the Ultimate Upvote as S&P 500 Forces Bogleheads to Buy the Degen Mothership (+13%)
The S&P moderators have approved the post…
Over the last decade, Reddit channels have spent an obscene amount of characters telling strangers to stop picking stocks and buy the S&P 500. Well, guess what? Very soon, anyone buying the S&P 500 will be forced to automatically buy the stock..
Alexa, play “Circle of Life.”
That’s right, my fellow degens (or should I call you an “institutional degen” now)... shares are up 13% after S&P Dow Jones Indices announced the social-media company will join the S&P 500 before trading opens August 18.
Specifically, Reddit will replace AvalonBay Communities, which is being acquired by Equity Residential.
In other words, one apartment landlord ate another apartment landlord… and the vacant seat went to the website where tenants complain about both of them.
The promotion means every fund manager tracking the S&P 500 will now have to buy Reddit shares to match the benchmark.
Passive investors: I would never invest in Reddit.
S&P 500: You already did.
Reddit becomes only the second pure-play social-media company in the index behind Meta. Pinterest and Snap remain trapped at the kids’ table, while Twitter was removed after Elon Musk bought it in 2022 and renamed it X.
The promotion came quickly. Reddit went public in March 2024, raised $748 million, and reached America’s most important stock index in less than 30 months.
Still, the celebratory upvotes arrive with one rather inconvenient footnote: Reddit shares were down 31% this year through yesterday’s close.
The selloff would make more sense if Reddit’s actual numbers sucked. (Spoiler alert: They didn’t.)
Reddit reported its eighth consecutive quarter of revenue growth above 60% in July, with second-quarter sales jumping 61% to $805 million. Profit more than doubled, while daily active users climbed 18%.
So what was the problem?
Shares still fell 20% after Reddit admitted search referrals were “choppy,” primarily because Google’s Gemini AI Overviews are answering questions with Reddit’s content before users reach Reddit.
Why click the original Reddit thread when Google can summarize 847 confidently incorrect comments for you?
That leaves Reddit in a beautifully dysfunctional relationship with Google.
Google sends Reddit users, pays Reddit$60 million per year to train AI on its content, and then uses that AI to stop people from visiting Reddit.
Reddit CEO Steve Huffman has said the company is still searching for a “win-win,” while Reddit reportedly wants its next Google licensing agreement priced according to usage instead of a flat annual fee.
That makes sense considering Reddit now holds more than 26 billion posts and comments from over 130 million daily active users… an enormous archive of human knowledge, personal trauma, questionable medical advice, and people lying about how much money they make.
OpenAI has also signed a data-licensing agreement with Reddit, helping transform the company from “website full of weirdos” into “valuable supplier of premium AI training material.”
Even still, the company’s addition to the S&P 500 gives Reddit something even better than another licensing deal: a built-in stream of buyers.
Beginning Tuesday, funds tracking the S&P 500 will automatically add Reddit, meaning millions of responsible investors will become partial owners of r/WallStreetBets without ever downloading Robinhood.
At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News holds positions in Meta, Snap, Google, and Robinhood as mentioned in the article.