Musk Found Liable for Misleading Twitter Investors in Buyout Runup

A California jury found that Elon Musk made false or misleading statements to Twitter investors during the runup to his 2022 purchase of the company.

The decision focused on Musk’s public remarks in May 2022, including posts that questioned Twitter’s disclosures about bots and fake accounts. Those comments coincided with a nearly 10% one-day drop in Twitter shares and became a central issue in the class-action case brought by former shareholders.

Musk’s lawyers at Quinn Emanuel said in an emailed statement that the verdict was mixed, noting that jurors rejected the claim that he carried out a broader fraud scheme. The firm said it viewed the outcome as “a bump in the road” and expects to seek vindication on appeal.

The jury nevertheless unanimously found after four days of deliberations that Musk’s May 13 and May 17 statements were materially false or misleading. Plaintiffs said those remarks hurt shareholders who sold stock below the $54.20 per share price Musk had agreed to pay in the acquisition.

Attorneys for the investor group said damages could total as much as $2.6 billion. They said that estimate is based on expert analysis of the effect Musk’s shifting public comments had on Twitter’s share price during the class period.

The lawsuit, Pampena v. Musk, was filed in October 2022 after Musk completed the $44 billion acquisition of Twitter. He later renamed the platform X, and it was subsequently combined with xAI and later with SpaceX, according to the information provided. Former Twitter shareholders, including retail investors and options traders, argued that Musk’s remarks were intended to pressure Twitter’s board into accepting a lower price. They also claimed he had reason to push the stock down because declines in Tesla shares could have forced him to sell more stock in the automaker to finance the deal.

Musk’s defense argued that his statements reflected legitimate concerns about spam, bots, and fake accounts on the platform, and did not amount to securities fraud. Jurors agreed he did not engage in a specific scheme to defraud investors, even while finding that some of his statements were false or misleading.

Lawyers for the plaintiffs said it may take about 90 days to establish the claims administration process, followed by additional time for claims to be processed and payments to begin.

Joseph Cotchett, an attorney for the plaintiffs, said after the verdict that the case was meant to address harm to ordinary investors, including people with retirement accounts and pension exposure.

About X

X, formerly known as Twitter, was founded in 2006 and is based in San Francisco, California. The company operates a social media platform built around real-time communication, advertising, and digital content sharing. Elon Musk acquired the company in 2022 for about $44 billion and later rebranded it as X.