Lulu Investors Squat-Test New CEO Pick (Spoiler: It Did Not Pass)
Live look at Lulu investors on yesterday's news…
"Transparent" is the word the analysts used on Lulu's CEO pick. It's also the word they've used on the last two legging lines. In both cases they meant it the bad way. Stock cratered 13%.
In short, Lululemon was sent to the gulag yesterday after the board named former Nike president of consumer, product and brand Heidi O'Neill its next CEO, with a start date of September 8. She succeeds Calvin McDonald, whose seven-year run ended in January under back-to-back see-through legging scandals, a 55% stock fade, and a founder-led proxy fight.
For context, O'Neill was a principal architect of Nike's Consumer Direct Offense, the wholesale-divorce strategy that torched Nike's margins, drowned its inventory, and got the company sued for securities fraud. She's a named defendant on that lawsuit (not an ex-colleague of the defendants, but a defendant herself). Woof.
BNP Paribas analyst Laurent Vasilescu said the quiet part out loud on this shindig: "Lululemon needs a turnaround CEO, not a growth CEO." Translation: they hired the fire starter to put out a fire.
The executioners activists at Elliott Investment Management, sitting on a $1 billion Lulu stake, had a different candidate in mind: former Ralph Lauren CFO Jane Nielsen, a person who actually runs turnarounds for a living (which, funny enough, is something you really can't do in Lulu's see through leggings). Lulu picked the Nike brand builder instead.
But alas, keep in mind that Blue-Chip Wilson, the founder and owner of 4.3% of the float, is already running his own proxy fight with three nominated directors and a WSJ ad that called Lululemon "in a nosedive." So this pick definitely doesn’t help him out of the maze he’s already put himself in.
And it all starts with the math. Over the last twelve months, DTC market share slid from 30% to 24%, Alo climbed to 14%, and Vuori now shares half its shopper base with Lulu. North America comps dropped another 4% last quarter and total revenue grew 1% to $3.6 billion. For a brand whose entire pitch is premium pricing for innovation nobody can copy, 1% growth reads as bare minimum.
O'Neill, for her part, promised to "build on the foundation," "accelerate product breakthroughs," and "deepen the brand's cultural relevance"… which is the press release you'd expect from a growth CEO, and the press release that convinced exactly nobody yesterday. Of course, O'Neill can't actually start until September 8. She's contractually tethered to Nike for another five months… which means Lulu, a company the activists say is on fire, just told its investors they're going to watch the smoke for a full quarter before the new CEO is even allowed to pick up a hose. Meghan Frank and André Maestrini share the wheel until then. In the meantime, the squat test remains undefeated.
Until next time, friends…

At the time of publishing, Stocks.News does not hold positions in companies mentioned in the article.