Investors Snicker at Target’s “Concepts of a Plan” as Traffic Falls for Fourth Straight Quarter
“Would you like to supersize that?” -Target CEO Michael Fiddelke at his new job if he doesn’t get his sh*t together ASAP
Target wants everyone to know that they have “concepts of a plan” to end its sales slump which started when Walmart committed the largest form of identity theft ever.
This comes after the big red bullseye served up yet another quarter of shrinking revenue and lighter foot traffic. Holiday sales hit $30.45 billion, down 1.5% year over year. Comparable sales slid 2.5%. Store comps? Down 3.9%.
Apparently the Target run turned into a Target jog… in the opposite direction.
That said… there might be a flicker at the end of the red-and-white tunnel. Adjusted EPS came in at $2.44 vs. $2.16 expected. So while the top line was out here auditioning to be Walmart’s intern, the bottom line showed the retail war is far from over. And yes, net income still slipped to $1.05B from $1.10B, but Wall Street ignored that because, “beat is a beat.”
Naturally, this unfolds while Fiddelke, fresh to the throne as of Feb. 1, is marketing this turnaround like it’s buy-one-get-one-free.
In an attempt to scare short sellers away… he argued trends improved in the last two months of the quarter. According to him, February sales even turned positive year-over-year. This is an “important milestone,” per the press release. The “look at the future we’re creating together” type speech.
For the full year, Target expects sales to rise about 2%, with growth every quarter. So essentially: slight growth… if everything goes right (which it never does).
Unfortunately, there’s a YUGE problem that investors aren’t going to just ignore. Traffic has now fallen four quarters in a row and annual sales have been roughly flat for four years.
The chart’s not looking so hot either. Shares are down nearly 32% over three years (though up about 16% this year). Meanwhile, rivals like Walmart, Costco, and TJX Companies (read: TJ Maxx) are out here printing comps like stimulus checks just dropped.
In response, Target chopped 1,800 corporate jobs and has invested more in store labor after customers complained about messy aisles and checkout lines longer than a DMV line.
They even admitted backlash from its DEI rollback hurt sales and cost market share… which might be proof they’ve hit a new low.
But the biggest story to me is that ever since Walmart hit copy+paste on Targets whole flow… the white girl paradise has lost it’s “aura” (as the kids say). And I don’t know if they’ll ever be able to get it back.
At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News doesn’t hold positions in companies mentioned in the article.