Hershey’s Spooky SZN Sales Get Trick-or-Deleted as 11% Price Hikes Scare off Halloween Shoppers

Kid: “What are you gonna be for Halloween?”

Reese’s sales: “Apparently a ghost.”

And just when you thought Hershey's Reese's recipe controversy couldn't get any more embarrassing…

Willy Wonka's corporate descendants have managed to price chocolate so aggressively that Americans are considering handing out loose change instead.

Congratulations, Hershey. You've made free candy too expensive.

According to NielsenIQ, Halloween candy sales plunged 6.7% in the month ending October 17 compared to last year.

That's actually an improvement from mid-September, when sales were down 11.7%.

Michael Myers called. Even he thinks these numbers are a little disturbing. 

And Hershey CEO Kirk Tanner isn't exactly expecting the Great Pumpkin to save the quarter.

Speaking to investors Thursday, Tanner warned that financially strapped Americans could be tightening their candy budgets just days before Halloween.

"The last few days are really critical," Tanner said, practically begging consumers to make one final pilgrimage to the candy aisle.

“I'm once again asking for your financial support.” -Bernie Sanders Hershey’s CEO

Of course, it doesn't take a forensic accountant to figure out why folks are suddenly rationing their Reese's.

Hershey raised prices 11% during the third quarter.

And in a development that caught absolutely nobody in corporate America by surprise, customers responded by buying around 7% less candy.

Economists are reportedly working around the clock to understand this phenomenon.

Meanwhile, it’s not just Halloween giving Hershey nightmares.

The chocolate maker reported third-quarter revenue of $3.28 billion, narrowly beating estimates of $3.25 billion.

But organic sales grew a miserable 0.8%, prompting management to lower its full-year organic growth forecast to 3%, down from its previous 3% to 3.5% range.

Convenience stores have been particularly fugly.

Candy, gum, and mint sales at U.S. convenience stores fell nearly 5% in September, with weakness continuing into October.

But surely Hershey has considered the radical idea of lowering prices to win back customers?

HAHAHAHA. Good one.

Despite falling volumes, management has no plans for broad price cuts.

Instead, it's betting on smaller packages, promotions, and new products like Hershey Creme Filled Bars and Reese's Oreos to lure customers back.

“We heard your concerns about affordability. So we made the prices lower package smaller.”

Still, there's one silver lining for investors.

Falling cocoa prices and tariff refunds helped Hershey raise its annual earnings growth outlook, although higher freight costs and consumer pressures could restrain growth in 2027.

Meanwhile, the National Retail Federation expects Americans to spend $13.5 billion on Halloween candy this year, compared with $13.1 billion in 2025.

So the money is technically still out there.

Hershey just needs Americans to spend more of it on chocolate before Saturday night.

At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News doesn’t hold positions in companies mentioned in the article.