Gap Treats Its Chronic 'Athleta's Foot' With a Third CEO Since 2023 (Shares Pop 11%)
Stop trying to make 'Fashiontainment' happen…
Sooo apparently, the only thing actually printing at Gap is… Gap.
Gap Inc. (the company that owns Gap, Old Navy, Banana Republic and Athleta, in order of competence) beat on the bottom line in Q3, with adjusted earnings of 82 cents a share vs. 78 cents expected. Revenue whiffed by a whole $10M ($4.01B vs. $4.02B expected), and overall same-store sales were flat.
Which brings me to the namesake putting the whole family on its back. Gap brand comps jumped 9%, its 12th straight positive quarter, helped by a multiyear "Fashiontainment" partnership (read: a boy band named JYT). It also dropped a second round of Hailey Bieber jeans. Turns out Gap has great jeans (sup, Sydney).
The rest of the kids? Not so much. Athleta, the Lululemon-we-have-at-home, saw sales crater 14% to $220M, and comps fell 15%. Its new customers didn't make up for the regulars it lost, so it discounted more. Barbie's old boss (read: Gap CEO Richard Dickson) told CNBC he's "disappointed," and that Athleta has gone from "rebuild mode" to "turnaround mode," which is code for "it got worse."
Friendly reminder, the new boss will be Athleta's third CEO since 2023. Ex-Alo exec Chris Blakeslee got the job in 2023 and was out by 2025. His replacement, 20-year Nike vet Maggie Gauger, lasted about 14 months before Lululemon poached her in October to fix its famously see-through product line. Starting Dec. 14, Athleta will be run by Ashley Kechter, the global president of Vuori, which has been eating Lululemon's lunch for years. Translation: These hoes CEOs ain't loyal.
As for Old Navy, the biggest brand at $2.3B in sales, comps were flat in its new CEO's first quarter. Gap called that a "meaningful sequential improvement" (comps fell 4% last quarter, so… technically). Its fall denim campaign starred Cardi B, a self-admitted former Old Navy shoplifter. Banana Republic's sales slipped 3% after its women's fall lineup was "overweighted towards cold weather categories" and, per Dickson, didn't get "the fashion and color point of view right." Woof.
Which brings us to the weather. Gap cut its full-year outlook to flat sales (from growth of 1% to 1.5%) and adjusted EPS of $2.29 to $2.34 (from $2.35 to $2.45). Dickson pinned most of the cut on a warm start to the holiday quarter, after the warmest October in 10 years killed demand for sweaters and outerwear. Ok, fair, except Gap brand grew 9% under the same sun…
Of course, investors didn't care. Shares ripped more than 11% Friday, since the stock was already down about 25% this year. That sound you hear is Wall Street giving Dick a Gluck Gluck 9000 for cutting guidance.
Dickson swears shoppers will be back once it gets cold. Makes sense. People with no taste and less money have to shop somewhere (me).
Godspeed, Ashley…

At the time of publishing, Stocks.News does not hold positions in companies mentioned in the article.