Elon’s Bot Panic Comes Back to Haunt Him as the $44B Twitter Deal Lands in Court
“Did I manipulate the stock?” -Elon Musk, probably while scrolling memes during cross-examination.
Remember Twitter? The little blue bird that Elon Musk grabbed by the neck in 2022, renamed X, stapled to an AI company, and then loosely merged with a rocket manufacturer that’s rumored to shatter the IPO market records?
Yeah… that saga isn’t done yet.
Because very soon, Musk will have to explain to a judge why the $44 billion Twitter deal didn’t involve him playing stock-price ping-pong with investors.
Back in April 2022, the EV wizard announced he’d buy Twitter for $54.20 per share (which at the time got a “holy overpay” reaction). Wall Street assumed the deal was locked.
Then things got weird. Musk started tweeting about bots, complaining about fake accounts, hinting the deal might be “on hold”, and generally behaving like Michael Scott right after signing the condo mortgage. Only for Dwight Schrute to pull out a spreadsheet and explain he won’t have it paid off until he’s a grandpa. In other words: a brutal case of buyer’s remorse.
Naturally, this caused Twitter stock to start wobbling. More specifically, it fell 35-40% below Elon’s offer price.
Well, you’ll never guess what’s happening now. Investors now claim Musk was deliberately trashing the platform to push the price down and pressure the board into renegotiating the deal.
Their argument is that some shareholders sold early at prices below $54.20 because they thought Musk might bail.
Translation: “Your stupid tweets made me lose my shirt… and you’re now the richest man in the world. Tell that man to bring me my money.”
Musk’s lawyers (who I guarantee are tired af of the neverending lawsuits) say that’s nonsense and that he never intended to harm investors.
Of course, at one point Musk tried to walk away from the deal completely. Twitter responded the way any company would when $44 billion is involved: they sued him immediately in Delaware. That courtroom showdown never happened because Musk eventually folded and bought the company at the original price.
Cue the weird rebrand.
Shortly after, Twitter became X, the social network got merged with Musk’s AI startup xAI, and then somehow got stapled onto SpaceX, the rocket company that also runs Starlink.
Private investors now value the entire Musk ecosystem at roughly $1.25 trillion, which is either brilliant corporate synergy or the most chaotic org chart in human history.
But the legal fun doesn’t stop there. Because the SEC also has a few questions for Elon. Regulators claim he violated disclosure rules by waiting too long to reveal his growing Twitter stake before launching the takeover bid. Turns out Musk revealed a 9.1% stake only AFTER he had already been buying shares for weeks.
In the SEC’s world, that’s a “gotcha b****” moment.
In Elon’s world, on the other hand… deadlines are more of a suggestion between meme posts.
So what does all this mean? Well, to put simply, if Musk loses the civil fraud case, he could be forced to compensate investors BIGLY who say they lost money during the buyout roller coaster.
And it could ripple into other lawsuits tied to the takeover.
But Musk showing up in court also comes at a pretty interesting moment. Because while he’s explaining the Twitter saga to a judge… SpaceX is (not so quietly) preparing for one of the biggest IPOs in history.
Meaning the guy who turned Twitter into X and welded it onto an AI startup and a rocket company now has to answer a simple question:
Was it stock manipulation…
Or just Elon just having an indecisive moment?
At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News doesn’t hold positions in companies mentioned in the article.