$BA Pops as Boeing Wins the Navy's $20B F/A-XX Dogfight but Could Still 'Lose the War Chest'

"It's not the size of the contract, it's how much you lose on it…" (or whatever Boeing's accountants said) 

Talk about changing the subject. On Monday, Temu Airbus (read: Boeing) dropped nearly 7% after Southwest and United apparently refused to take new 737 Maxes running its glitchy flight software. By Tuesday night, the Pentagon had handed it the Navy's F/A-XX, the sixth-gen carrier fighter that'll replace Boeing's own Super Hornet, in a full-scale development deal worth north of $20 billion. 

Fun fact: That makes Boeing the builder of both of America's sixth-gen fighters, after #47 gave it the Air Force's F-47 in the Oval Office last year (sup, Lockheed). Northrop Grumman, the only other first loser finalist slid as much as 5% after hours. Its statement said it looks forward "to receiving additional information about their selection," which usually means lawyers.

$BA popped about 3% premarket to $193.41, adding roughly $4.5 billion in market value. Which sounds great, until you remember the stock ate sh*t to the tune of $10.8 billion on Monday.

Friendly reminder, Boeing has a habit of underbidding to win, then losing money the moment it does. When it won the Navy's MQ-25 drone contract in 2018, its own 10-Q says it booked a $291 million "reach-forward loss" (ayy) "in connection with winning the competition." That same year, it won the Air Force's T-7A trainer jet and booked a $400 million loss on day one. Which, congrats?

Now, a reach-forward loss is what happens when a company expects a contract to lose money over its lifetime, so it has to book the whole loss upfront. That mostly happens on fixed-price contracts, where Boeing eats every dollar of cost overrun. The KC-46 tanker alone has lost Boeing more than $7 billion that way, and the defense unit is still riding the struggle bus. A $280 million charge on the new Air Force One left the whole unit with a $15 million operating loss last quarter on $7.48 billion of revenue. Woof. 

As for F/A-XX, the contract terms are classified. Best case, it's cost-plus like the F-47 (read: Uncle Sam eats the overruns), which means no day-one charge, but a pretty thin fee until production kicks in sometime in the 2030s. Worst case, it's fixed-price or comes with pre-priced production options on jets nobody's finished designing, and Boeing books another loss right out of the gate.

"We'll make it up on volume." - Boeing, probably

Oh, and since the award landed Sept. 29, one day before Q3 ended, any loss booked at award would hit Boeing's Q3 numbers in late October. Regardless, the market just paid up for a big swingin' contract nobody's allowed to read.

Impressive. Very nice. Now let's see Boeing's Q3 10-Q…

Until next time, friends… 

At the time of publishing, Stocks.News holds position in United Airlines as mentioned in the article.