AT&T’s Earnings Beat Goes Up in Smoke as Starlink Threat Sends Shares -6% (CEO Denies Threat)

AT&T shares fell more than 6% Wednesday despite reporting stronger-than-expected third-quarter earnings and raising its full-year profit forecast. Investors were more concerned about slowing wireless subscriber growth, falling broadband revenue per customer, and the growing threat from Elon Musk's Starlink network.

The company reported revenue of $32.3 billion, up 5.3% from a year earlier and ahead of estimates of $31.7 billion. Adjusted earnings came in at 65 cents a share, beating expectations of 60 cents, while AT&T raised its full-year profit forecast to around $2.40 a share from its previous range of $2.25 to $2.35.

On paper, there wasn't much to complain about. Adjusted EBITDA increased 5.4% to $12.5 billion, and the company generated $5 billion in free cash flow during the quarter.

The problem is that AT&T is having to work harder to attract customers, and those customers aren't necessarily paying as much as they used to.

AT&T added 379,000 postpaid phone subscribers during the quarter, down from 432,000 in the second quarter and 405,000 a year earlier. That was almost exactly what analysts expected, but it offered little reassurance to investors looking for signs of accelerating wireless growth.

The broadband business was a different story. AT&T added a record 769,000 internet subscribers, including 442,000 fiber customers and 327,000 fixed-wireless customers.

Much of that growth is coming from a strategy of offering discounts to households that purchase both home internet and mobile phone service. About 43% of customers subscribing to AT&T's advanced internet services also have its wireless plans.

The thinking is that customers who get both services from AT&T will be less likely to switch providers, making the upfront discounts worth it over time.

But those discounts are beginning to show up in the numbers.

Average revenue per fiber customer declined 4% in the third quarter, reflecting promotional pricing, introductory offers, and lower-paying customers added through AT&T's $5.75 billion acquisition of Lumen's consumer fiber business.

Management expects that decline to continue into the fourth quarter.

Analysts suggested AT&T's recent fiber price increases could be a sign that management is questioning whether aggressive discounts are bringing in enough additional customers to justify the lower revenue.

Meanwhile, another potential competitor is giving investors something to think about.

SpaceX's Starlink Mobile service surpassed 22 million monthly users during the quarter, up 37% from the previous three months. And with SpaceX outlining plans to expand into terrestrial wireless services, investors are beginning to consider what a more direct challenge to traditional carriers might look like.

AT&T CEO John Stankey isn't convinced satellites can replace the infrastructure his company has spent decades building. During Wednesday's earnings call, he argued that satellite networks could be useful in rural areas but would struggle to match terrestrial wireless performance in densely populated cities and indoor environments.

Those concerns weren't limited to AT&T. Shares of Verizon and T-Mobile also fell approximately 3% Wednesday.

For the time being, AT&T is sticking with its longer-term plans. The company expects more than $18 billion in free cash flow this year, rising to at least $19 billion in 2027 and $21 billion in 2028. It also plans roughly $10 billion in share repurchases during 2026 and more than $45 billion in combined dividends and buybacks through 2028.

At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News holds positions in AT&T and Verizon as mentioned in the article.