AT&T Pays $184M to Bury Pension Lawsuit as Decades-Old Retirement Assumptions Come Undone
Pension calculations aren't exactly the kind of thing most employees spend much time thinking about during their careers. But they became a very expensive issue for AT&T this week.
On Thursday, the company agreed to pay $184.1 million to settle a class-action lawsuit alleging it shortchanged about 300,000 current and former employees by using outdated actuarial assumptions when calculating certain pension benefits.
The case hinged on mortality tables that AT&T allegedly hadn't updated in decades.
According to the lawsuit, AT&T relied on life expectancy data that were decades out of date when calculating pension payments for married employees who elected joint-and-survivor annuities, a common retirement option that continues making payments to a surviving spouse after the retiree dies.
Under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), different pension payment options are generally required to be "actuarially equivalent," meaning each option should provide the same economic value over a participant's expected lifetime.
Well, the plaintiffs argued that wasn't happening.
Because Americans today generally live longer than they did when many of those mortality tables were created, employees claimed the outdated assumptions resulted in married workers receiving lower monthly pension payments than they were entitled to under federal law.
Of course, AT&T denied any wrongdoing.
The company said it agreed to settle simply to avoid the expense, uncertainty, and distraction of prolonged litigation, while maintaining that it has administered its pension plans in compliance with federal law.
If approved by the court, about $149.1 million of the settlement will go directly toward additional pension benefits, including approximately $113.5 million for retired employees and $35.6 million for current workers still participating in the pension plan. Plaintiffs' attorneys may also seek up to $35 million in legal fees and litigation costs.
The lawsuit has been working its way through federal court since October 2020.
While the settlement resolves AT&T's case, the issues it raises extend far beyond one company.
Although many employers have shifted toward 401(k)-style retirement plans over the past few decades, millions of Americans are still covered by traditional pensions that require companies to make complex assumptions about life expectancy, interest rates, and future payment obligations.
Those assumptions don't stay accurate forever.
As Americans continue living longer, mortality tables are periodically updated to reflect changing life expectancies. Even relatively small changes to those assumptions can affect monthly pension payments, particularly for retirees who choose survivor benefits for their spouses.
When those differences are applied across hundreds of thousands of employees over many years, the financial impact can become significant.
That's one reason pension litigation has become increasingly common.
Several large employers have faced lawsuits challenging the actuarial assumptions used to calculate retirement benefits, with plaintiffs arguing that outdated mortality data or interest rate assumptions reduced payouts below the levels required under ERISA.
AT&T's settlement doesn't establish that those claims are valid across the board, nor does it include any admission of liability.
But it does illustrate how technical decisions buried deep inside pension formulas can eventually translate into hundreds of millions of dollars in legal exposure.
Still, it's another headline AT&T probably didn't need. Shares have already fallen 13% this year, and while the settlement is unlikely to materially change the company's outlook, it adds to a growing list of issues investors have had to digest.
At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News holds positions in AT&T as mentioned in the article.