Apple’s OpenAI Lawsuit Sends Oracle Spiraling as S&P Reveals a $300B OpenAI Dependency (RUN!)

Who knew the biggest loser in the entire Elon/Sam Altman Twitter dispute would be... Larry Ellison? 

Yesterday Oracle shares got sent to the gulag after news broke over the weekend that Apple sued OpenAI, accusing the company of systematically poaching employees and stealing trade secrets related to future hardware products.

Oracle finished the day down more than 6%, closing at $131.54, literally pennies above its 52-week low and now sitting 62% below its all-time high.

At first glance, the selloff looks ridiculous. The lawsuit is about hardware designs. Oracle rents OpenAI cloud infrastructure. Correct me if I’m wrong, but those two things have about as much in common as Roaring Kitty and Warren Buffett.

If OpenAI loses the lawsuit tomorrow, it won't suddenly forget how to pay Oracle's invoices. Which is why I don't think the lawsuit was actually the story. I think it simply reminded Mr. Market of something he had already started figuring out a few days earlier. 

Last week, S&P downgraded Oracle's credit rating to BBB-. For those of you who have better things to do than read credit reports on a Saturday night, that's the last stop before junk status.

But the downgrade itself wasn't the scary part. It was why S&P downgraded it. For the first time, a major ratings agency told investors that nearly half of Oracle's $638 billion backlog comes from one customer who’s CEO just happens to be Scam Altman.

That's a lot of eggs in one AI-shaped basket. Which becomes a lot more scary once you realize Oracle has already bet tens of billions that OpenAI keeps showing up with a checkbook. 

Last fiscal year the company spent about $55.7 billion on capital expenditures. That's a 162% increase from the year before.

It also blew past its own guidance. Free cash flow ended up negative $23.7 billion, and S&P believes the cash burn could reach $42 billion next year.  Meanwhile Oracle is carrying somewhere around $160 billion of debt.

Translation: this isn't really an earnings story anymore. It's a financing story. 

Because once you're spending tens of billions every year building AI data centers, your credit rating instantly matters a lot more than your P/E ratio.

If Oracle gets pushed into junk territory, borrowing becomes more expensive. Building data centers becomes more expensive. Everything becomes more expensive.

Which means the entire AI expansion depends even more on one very important question… Can OpenAI keep writing enormous checks?

That's why S&P's footnote may have mattered more than Oracle's earnings report. A backlog only has value if the customer paying for it stays financially healthy. And sadly for our friend Larry, the market finally started connecting those dots.

Now throw Oracle's insider selling into the mix. Back in June, Vice Chairman Jeffrey Henley exercised 400,000 stock options before they expired and immediately sold every single share.

On its own, exercising expiring options isn't unusual. Selling every share instead of keeping any? Not exactly a great sign. It doesn't prove anything. But it certainly doesn't scream, "Load the boat."

Now let's compare that to Microsoft for a second. It also has massive exposure to OpenAI. 

So what’s the difference? Microsoft has one of the strongest balance sheets on planet earth. On the flipside, Oracle is borrowing aggressively to build infrastructure while hoping its biggest customer keeps raising more money. Those are two very different risk profiles.

If I had to guess, the Apple lawsuit may end up being completely irrelevant. The case is focused on alleged trade secrets tied to hardware ambitions, not OpenAI's ability to pay cloud bills.

If anything, it simply gave investors an excuse to finally price the credit story that had been sitting in plain sight since S&P released its downgrade.

Could Oracle bounce? Absolutely. If OpenAI announces another monster funding round tomorrow, this entire narrative probably reverses overnight. That's the nature of a stock that's become increasingly tied to one customer.

Until then, Oracle isn't really trading like an enterprise software company anymore. It's trading like a very expensive wager that OpenAI's funding machine never breaks. And that's a much riskier bet than the Apple lawsuit headline made it seem.

At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News holds positions in Apple and Microsoft as mentioned in the article.