Apple Changes the Locks After Meta’s 2.5M-Download Muse AI Sparks a Mac Privacy Fight

For a long time, privacy has been one of Apple’s favorite ways to distinguish itself from the rest of Big Tech. But the rise of AI agents is making that promise more complicated.

The company said Friday it plans to tighten how macOS handles requests for Full Disk Access, one of the operating system’s most powerful permissions, as increasingly autonomous AI tools seek deeper access to users’ personal data.

Unlike iPhones and iPads, where apps are generally sandboxed and prevented from accessing information stored inside other apps, Macs offer more flexibility. Users can grant applications Full Disk Access, allowing software such as cloud backup services to reach data across the machine.

That arrangement made sense when the software asking for access was primarily backing up files. It becomes more consequential when the application is an AI agent capable of reading information, connecting with other services and taking actions on a user’s behalf.

Apple said some developers have begun using Full Disk Access in ways that could expose users to additional risk.

“Going forward, we will introduce additional controls to ensure that users who genuinely wish to grant an app this extraordinary level of access can only do so with very explicit user action,” Apple said.

The company said those safeguards have become increasingly important as AI software grows more capable.

“As AI agents become increasingly capable and autonomous, the risks associated with this level of access will grow substantially,” Apple said.

Apple didn’t identify any developer or application in its announcement. But the changes come as Meta’s Muse AI agent faces scrutiny over how it handles private information stored on Macs.

Inc. technology columnist Jason Aten recently said Muse appeared to access private conversations from Apple’s Messages app that he believed he had not authorized it to read.

Meta, shockingly, disputes that account.

Spokesperson Andy Stone said Muse can only access Messages after a user separately enables both Full Disk Access and the Messages connector. He also said the permissions can be revoked at any time.

To be clear, Apple isn’t accusing Meta of secretly accessing users’ messages, and Meta maintains that Muse requires explicit permission before doing so.

Still, the dispute highlights a larger problem emerging as AI assistants evolve from chatbots into agents.

The more useful these products become, the more information they may need.

An AI assistant that can access a user’s calendar, messages, email, files and browser activity can potentially book appointments, complete forms, make purchases and handle other tasks with relatively little input. But granting that access also raises the stakes when users don’t fully understand what they have approved.

Apple is now trying to make that tradeoff harder to miss.

The issue is particularly relevant because consumers don’t appear to be waiting for the privacy debate to get settled before trying the technology.

Muse surpassed 2.5 million downloads during its first two weeks after launch, signaling substantial early interest in AI agents capable of performing tasks across different apps and services.

And that growing adoption creates another challenge for Apple… AI agents aren’t just a privacy issue. They could eventually become a competitive one.

Apple currently controls much of what happens on its devices through the operating system, App Store and its own services. But if consumers increasingly turn to an AI agent to search for products, compare prices, book travel or make purchases, more of those interactions could happen through software built by another company.

Bank of America analyst Wamsi Mohan recently warned that this could threaten parts of Apple’s services business even if it doesn’t materially weaken demand for the iPhone itself.

In that scenario, Apple could continue owning the device while another company increasingly controls what users do after they unlock it.

That helps explain why the Full Disk Access debate matters beyond a single privacy complaint.

Apple has an important advantage in that fight because it still controls macOS. Third-party AI agents may become increasingly sophisticated, but Apple determines what permissions those agents can request and how clearly users must approve them.

For years, Full Disk Access was primarily a tool for applications that needed unusually broad access to perform relatively narrow functions.

AI agents change that equation.

They are designed to do more precisely because they can see more.

Apple now has to figure out how to give them enough access to remain useful without making one of the Mac’s most powerful permissions something users grant without understanding the consequences.

The company hasn’t said exactly when the additional controls will arrive. But its decision to tighten them suggests Apple believes the existing permission model needs to evolve alongside the software requesting access.

At the time of publishing this article, Stocks.News holds positions in Meta and Apple as mentioned in the article.