American Airlines Pistol Whips Guidance for Third Straight Time (Loyalty? Never heard of her…)

American Airloss, anyone? 

For the third time this year, Temu Delta (read: American Airlines) stood up in front of investors, looked at its own 2026 profit forecast, and kicked shareholders' teeth in. The carrier now expects to earn somewhere between negative 65 cents and positive 65 cents a share this year, which isn't guidance so much as a horoscope. Shares dropped about 8% in early trading Thursday because of it. 

In short, back in January, American told everyone to pencil in $1.70 to $2.70 a share. By April that had slipped to a loss of 40 cents up to a profit of $1.10. Now it's a coin flip hovering around breakeven. Three cuts in seven months is a special kind of f*ckery, and the excuse each time is jet fuel, which has bounced around all summer near $4 a gallon and torched more than $4 billion onto the airline's costs this year (fuel is its biggest expense after labor, so that's not a bean counting error).

That said, what makes the cut sting even worse is that the quarter American actually reported was fine. It earned 15 cents a share adjusted against the 3 cents Wall Street penciled in, and revenue landed at $16.74 billion, a touch above estimates. Passenger revenue per available seat mile, the industry's pricing-power gauge, climbed 10%. Net income still fell 88% from a year ago to $71 million, but demand held and fares held. Then management started talking about the rest of the year. For the current quarter, American guided to an adjusted loss of as much as 70 cents a share. Wall Street had been modeling a 28-cent profit. And yet, on the earnings call, executives defended a plan to keep expanding, adding up to 5% more flying straight into $4 fuel (read: when the product isn't selling at a profit, the fix is apparently more product). It forecast revenue up 16% to 19%, which is the one number that beat expectations.

However, there is one teeny weeny gap. And that’s what the collective uproaring is all about. See, United out-earned American by roughly $3 billion last year. Delta lapped it by something closer to $5 billion. CEO Robert Isom's answer, delivered to CNBC last month, is a "long-range" plan to close that gap with no timeframe attached (read: not soon). The plan itself is to order new wide-body jets and bolt more premium seats onto older ones, chasing the fat premium-cabin margins Delta already prints. "While there's still work ahead, the progress we're making is real," Isom told staff Thursday. Sure. So is the roughly $35 billion in debt he's building his House of Cards on. 

Oh, and to really make this all go t*ts up, the “comeback” is being funded by the people least likely to get horned up over it. For instance, while guidance was getting slashed, American spent the first half of the year hollowing out its own loyalty program, killing mileage earning on basic economy in December and, in May, yanking upgrades and seat selection from elite flyers the moment they book the cheap fare.

As you can imagine, the change lit up frequent-flyer forums for weeks (sup, keyboard warriors). Basic economy now boards dead last, in Group 9, which is coincidentally about where American sits behind Delta and United. To be fair though, the turnaround isn’t necessarily cancelled. It’s just delayed again, with no new departure time posted… please continue to enjoy your complimentary anxiety. Isom swears American will catch the leaders, and maybe someday it does. But you don't close a $3 billion gap by announcing it's on the way and all while charging your regulars out the a$$ for the privilege of watching. Check back next quarter, when there's a real chance the number gets worse. Again. Until next time, friends… 

At the time of publishing, Stocks.News holds positions in United Airlines as mentioned in the article.